It's Peanut Butter Jelly Time Service List

Jams & Butters

• MoonShadows Farm

  • Pumpkin Butter

  • Apple Butter

  • Strawberry Rhubarb

  • Damson Plum

  • Blueberry

  • Peach

  • Cinnamon Pear

  • Black Raspberry

  • Cherry

  • Elderberry

  • Strawberry

  • Cranberry Raspberry

  • Orange Marmalade

  • Raspberry Jalapeno

  • Rhubarb

  • Fig

  • Apircot

  • Red Raspberry

  • Black Berry Jalapeno

  • Peach Habanero

  • Strawberry Jalapeno

  • Black Berry

• Marty's Home Kitchen

  • Sour Cherry

  • Watermelon

  • Blueberry

  • Black Raspberry

  • Apricot

  • Cinnamon Apple

  • 3 Red Berry

  • Sugar Plum

  • Ginger Pear

  • Hot Pepper Spread

  • Strawberry

  • Mixed Berry

  • Cherry Blend

  • Quince Spread

  • Peach

Main Menu

• Gourmet Sandwiches

  • The Charlie Brown

    Peanut butter, choice of two jams, on white bread

    $3.75

  • The Messy Jessy

    Peanut butter, choice of two jams, and bananas on white bread

    $3.75

  • Aunt Lauraine

    Peanut butter and cream cheese on white bread

    $3.75

  • The Elvis

    Peanut butter, banana, and organic honey on toasted white bread

    $3.75

  • The Nutty Professor

    Peanut butter and Nutella on white bread

    $4.00

  • Uncle Tony

    Peanut butter, choice of Jam, banana, and Marshmallow Fluff on white bread

    $4.00

  • The Fluffy Nutter

    Peanut butter and Marshmallow Fluff on white bread

    $3.75

  • The DaVinci

    Peanut butter cream cheese and strawberry cream cheese on a toased bagel

    $4.50

  • The Big Dipper

    5 assorted nut butters served with, celery, carrots, and apple slices

    $8.00

  • The Home Run

    The Classic PB+J stacked Bigger to Knock it out the Park! Choice of jam on thick white bread.

    Double	$5.75
    Triple	$6.50

  • The Sticky Pig

    Peanut butter, local maple syrup and crispy bacon on white bread

    $5.50

  • The Works

    This Bad Boy is served on a 6" toasted hero roll stuffed with peanut butter, a full banana, choice of jam, Nutella, and Marshmallow Fluff

    $6.00

  • Frankie Peanut Butter

    Peanut butter, choice of jam and half a banana on a hot dog bun

    $3.00

  • Mishy's Jam

    Orange marmalade, cream cheese, and Marshmallow Fluff on thick toasted slices of Italian Bread

    $4.75

  • Peter, Pickle, + Paul

    Peanut butter, and sweet gherkin pickles on a hot dog bun

    $3.00

  • The Scotty 2 Hottie

    Peanut butter and choice of jam with an old fashioned oatmeal raisin cookie in between thick toasted slices of Italian Bread

    $4.75

  • Bugs on a Log

    Peanut butter filled celery sticks topped with raisins. This one will make you feel like a kid again

    $2.75

  • The Platter

    4 peanut butter sandwiches with choice of jams, 2 Frankie Peanut Butters, and a dozen cookies

    $15.99